Home Editorial E-cigarette ban: Moral fixation?

E-cigarette ban: Moral fixation?

EDITORIAL: Smokers, beware: A movement is afoot that will keep you toking out in the cold while everything you wear continues to smell like an ashtray.


Yes, no sooner has
someone devised a way of dealing with your addiction without hurting anyone else than self-appointed behavior police want to erect a mammoth obstacle to smokeless nicotine dispensers -- with their lipstick traces on it.

Bergen' freeholders were to vote today on whether to establish fines of up to $1,000 for inhaling from e-cigarettes in county buildings, public parks -- even in vehicles.

ecigs

Similar campaigns are under way in Connecticut, California, and Oregon. Lawmakers in Suffolk County, N.Y., have already instituted an indoor ban against the  smokeless lookalikes.

Imported from China, it's a simple device, really, with a replaceable cartridge and battery you can charge in a wall outlet, in your car, even through a USB cable.

When the user inhales, a water vapor containing a dose of nicotine is heated and released. Thus, a craving is satisfied. The smoker gets the oral fix, as well as the tactile feel of the e-cig between the fingers (And in case you're wondering: They do come in menthol, not to mention vanilla, caramel and coffee).

No value judgment, mind you. Even better: No carcinogens.

No preservatives. No whiffs, ash or butts.

NO CARBON MONOXIDE.

Actually, a better delivery system for society at large -- one that allows you to ingest nicotine without the toxic equivalent of sucking on an exhaust pipe AND eliminates second-hand smoke.

So when someone finally invents this marvelous little smoke on the water, what happens?

The Puritans line up alongside the tobacconists, just like they did in the 1700s.

Yes, there are risks -- namely propylene glycol, more commonly found in antifreeze, which is used as a propellant. The World Health Organization last year gave the e-cig the thumbs down, saying no proof exists of the producer's claim that it helps people quit smoking.

A quick analysis by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration earlier this year found enough traces of carcinogens and toxic chemicals in some e-cigarette cartridges to warrant further study.

Maybe the FDA should jump in with both feet before anyone starts firing up premature bans. Then again, that just might stir up the tobacco lobby.

Speaking of lobbies, you wanna take that outside, buddy?

(ED. NOTE: A New Jersey legislator has vowed to draft a measure sometime next month to cover the entire state; if/when it happens, we'll report it.)

 

Comments (2)add comment

Gina Gaffney said:

Gina Gaffney
...
As a long-time smoker (I know...ugh), I have tried everything out there to try to quit. I thought that e-cigs would be promising because, in theory, I'd still be getting my nic fix, without all the "bad" stuff that cigarettes have. I'm just about to purchase the e-cigarette, and I hear about how communities already want to ban them. They may have a point when it comes to public buildings, but....my car??? I don't think so.
 
October 07, 2009
Votes: +5

Patricia Clewell said:

Patricia Clewell
...
Thank you for this. I switched to an e-cig 7 months ago after smoking for more than 30 years--it's been a near miracle for me. The proposed ban on e-cigs has nothing to do with health or science and everything to do with an irrational and invasive moral crusade. If those who claim to be concerned with public health actually *were* concerned with public health, they'd be singing the e-cig's praises--not condemning it because it looks too much like smoking for their delicate emotional sensibilities. There's no secondhand smoke here, folks! No smoke at all, in fact! No smoke, no unpleasant odor, no ashes, no butts! This shouldn't even be an issue....
 
October 07, 2009
Votes: +10

Write comment
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
eleganttileadvertisement2
gotnews
cpsearch

kyrakvernophotography

robad

lynnparetportraits

cpvad1

bergenspaad001

ahad1

goldcoastappraisal2

mmgad1

robongiad2

tenadog

Public Safety

 

National Preparedness Month: It's not a celebration

September brings us not only the anniversary of the worst attack on U.S. soil: It’s also National Preparedness Month, a time when those responsible for our safety ask whether we’ve done what we can to help protect our families. So: How about checking this list to see how YOU measure up?

 

Critics of Bergen's first gun buy-back program are off-target

Naysayers are firing criticism at a gun buy-back program that netted more than 700 firearms this weekend, but Bergen County Sheriff Leo P. McGuire says they’re way off the mark.

 

Amber Alert nixed, Terry Dusseault and son found

UPDATE: Terry Dusseault and his 8-year-old son have been found, and New Jersey State Police have cancelled an Amber Alert.

 

No 'Kyleigh's Law' decal repeal: 6-month study instead

If Gov. Chris Christie goes along with it, state authorities will have six months to evaluate an unpopular law that requires young drivers to have red decals on their license plates -- a far cry from the repeal sought by several Bergen-area lawmakers and tens of thousands of New Jerseyans.

 

Firefighters helped catch wanted serial bank robbers

ONLY ON CVP: It’s no coincidence that New Jersey has the highest percentage of bank robbery arrests in the nation, not when there are people like the firefighters who helped lead to the arrest of two accused serial bank robbers.

 

String of high-figure bank jobs solved, FBI says

YOU READ IT HERE FIRST: Nathaniel Barreto of Newark admitted to being "the Black Stocking Robber" and Juan Perez of Clifton the wheelman in a string of bank holdups in Paramus, Boonton and elsewhere from North to Central Jersey that ended when they were tracked down following an armed robbery Tuesday, the FBI said.

 

Cops find new tactic: The Facebook perp walk

Posting mug shots on Facebook seemed a sweet idea for police in a small New Jersey town within spitting distance of Philadelphia -- only some people aren’t too crazy about it.

Connect

twittertagfeedtagfacebooktag

Shout Outs

 

Muscle Maker Grill celebration in Edgewater

No reason to let the weather keep you indoors. Muscle Maker Grill in Edgewater is celebrating an extremely successful first year down in Edgewater.

 

US judo champ Toni Marie Geiger of Dumont aims for 2012 Olympics

ONLY ON CLIFFVIEW PILOT: Because U.S. Olympic athletes don’t receive government funding, Toni Marie Geiger of Dumont -- the #1 ranked female judo athlete in the U.S. and a member of Team USA -- has to raise the money she needs to train, travel and compete herself to qualify for the 2012 Summer Games in London.

 

Hot on the teen scene: North Jersey's hard-rocking Odd Man In

Remember the days when you and your friends dreamed of starting a band? Well, it’s wonderful to watch a group of kids pursue their collective dream today -- which, in the case of Odd Man In, is a record deal. What makes it sweeter: The oldest is 15.

 

Beloved Union City educator taught students to believe in themselves

Jack O'Connor is being remembered with intense love and affection by hundreds of former students whose lives he touched. "He was a true man's man," former student John ODonnell Rosales said of one of Union City's most popular educators.

 

Ex-Passaic sheriff Englehardt, 80, 'sharp as a tack' after heat sends him to hospital, Speziale says

ONLY ON CVP: Passaic County Sheriff Jerry Speziale was driving on Route 80 when the radio crackled with the report of a disoriented driver who had blown a tire hitting a curb on Garrett Mountain. Imagine Speziale’s surprise when he pulled up to discover the motorist was his predecessor, perhaps the most legendary of all Passaic County political figures.

 

Those who knew Justin Sanchez recall 'that beautiful, bright smile'

ONLY ON CVP: Among those trying to make sense of the death of Justin Sanchez is Lucille Stanziale, who was there when the happy-go-lucky teen suffered a freak accident that killed him.